Cratylus by Plato
So, you want to know what's in this old book? It's basically a recorded chat. Three guys—Socrates, Hermogenes, and Cratylus—sit down to argue about names. Hermogenes thinks names are just whatever people decide to call something. There's no deeper reason a dog is a 'dog'; we just all agreed on that sound. Cratylus, on the other hand, is a true believer. He thinks names are naturally correct and reveal the core truth of what they name. Socrates, being Socrates, jumps in the middle. He pokes holes in both ideas, makes up funny and sometimes ridiculous word origins to prove a point, and leaves everyone (including the reader) wondering what to really think.
Why You Should Read It
This isn't a dry philosophy lecture. It's a lively, often humorous back-and-forth that feels incredibly modern. You get to watch Socrates' mind at work as he plays with language, showing how slippery and powerful words can be. The big questions here—do words shape our reality, or just describe it?—are questions we still wrestle with today in law, politics, and everyday life. Reading 'Cratylus' is like getting a front-row seat to the moment Western thought started seriously analyzing the tools we use to think and communicate.
Final Verdict
Perfect for anyone curious about philosophy but intimidated by heavier texts like 'The Republic.' It's also a great pick for word nerds, writers, or anyone who's ever had a late-night debate about the meaning of a word. It's short, focused, and packed with ideas that will stick with you. Just be warned: you might never look at a dictionary the same way again.
This book is widely considered to be in the public domain. It is now common property for all to enjoy.
Lisa Garcia
1 year agoHelped me clear up some confusion on the topic.
Margaret Brown
1 year agoI was skeptical at first, but it provides a comprehensive overview perfect for everyone. A valuable addition to my collection.
John Wright
2 years agoFrom the very first page, it creates a vivid world that you simply do not want to leave. Thanks for sharing this review.